Who can resist The Haunting!? The Mike Flanagan anthology series has a perfect way of scaring viewers while pulling at their heartstrings! Scroll below for the scariest episodes of Hill House and Bly Manor as voted by TV Time users.
12. Hill House “Two Storms” S1E6
Synopsis: It’s a reunion for all the wrong reasons when Hugh flies in for the funeral, coming face to face with his estranged children.
11. Bly Manor “The Romance of Certain Old Clothes” S2E8
Synopsis: Bly’s dark origins come to light once Viola, the iron-willed lady of the manor, becomes consumed by a monstrous rage.
10. Bly Manor “The Two Faces, Part Two” S2E7
Synopsis: Miles and Flora are pulled into a ghostly game.
9. Hill House “Touch” S1E3
Synopsis: Theo sees shades of herself in a troubled young patient — a girl who’s haunted by the menacing grin of “Mr. Smiley.”
8. Bly Manor “The Way It Came” S2E4
Synopsis: Racked with guilt, Dani is haunted by her own heartbreaking loss while the Bly staff remember the dead over a bonfire.
7. Hill House “Open Casket” S1E2
Synopsis: A devastating family tragedy stirs memories of traumatic losses, reminding Shirley of her first brush with death.
6. Bly Manor “The Two Faces: Part One” S2E3
Synopsis: Dani and Miles get an uncanny glimpse of the past, and the twisted history of Peter Quint and Rebecca Jessel casts a long shadow on the manor.
5. Hill House “The Bent-Neck Lady” S1E5
Synopsis: A dark specter with an unsettling silhouette has haunted Nell since she was a girl. Now “the Bent-Neck Lady” is back — and she’s calling Nell Home.
4. Hill House “Silence Lay Steadily” S1E8
Synopsis: The Red Room’s contents are finally revealed as the Crains return to the house to confront old ghosts, unspeakable secrets, and an insatiable evil.
3. Bly Manor “The Great Good Place” S2E1
Synopsis: An American au-pair hopes to make a difference caring for two orphans in a grand English manor. Yet the feeling of dread is undeniable.
2. Hill House “Steven Sees a Ghost” S1E1
Synopsis: While investigating a ghost story for his latest novel, a skeptical Steven receives a call from his sister that triggers a chain of fateful events.
1. Bly Manor “The Pupil” S2E2
Synopsis: After experiencing a harrowing scare, Dani tries to teach the children a lesson.
Disagree with the list? Be sure to add your reactions to the episodes that you track!
*The “Most Haunting Episodes of Hill House and Bly Manor” is based on in-app “scared” emotion votes in TV Time.