TV TIME

Join 10MM+ TV Lovers and Start Tracking!

Open in App

Contact - About - Data & Insights - Articles - Podcasts - Developers - Privacy Policy - Terms
Thanks

I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness
The CW
I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness (S04E05) is the fifth episode of season four of "One T... More I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness (S04E05) is the fifth episode of season four of "One Tree Hill" released on Wed Oct 25, 2006. Over 2,823 TV Time users rated it a 9.8/10 with their favorite characters being Chad Michael Murray as Lucas Scott, Hilarie Burton as Peyton Sawyer and James Lafferty as Nathan Scott.
  • Toze
  • Yves
  • TardisGirl
& 312,794 people watched this episode
  • 126
    comments
  • 2823
    emotions
  • 3092
    votes for best character

Why is this section hidden?

We simply wait until you mark this episode as watched before revealing discussions, ratings and special content... In case of spoilers!

Display anyway

126 reactions

Please wait...
×

PNG or JPG. Min width: 500px. Max size: 2Mo. Image must be about this episode.

May 2016

Nathan is the perfect boyfriend 💙

Nathan is the perfect boyfriend 💙
0 reply
March 2016

💓💓💓💓💓💓💓

💓💓💓💓💓💓💓
0 reply
January 2016

Nathan is the best 💕
His speech... He did the right thing, he always does.

Nathan is the best 💕 
His speech... He did the right thing, he always does.
0 reply
July 2016

i already love him

i already love him
0 reply
January 2016

This episode is fucking great!!!

This episode is fucking great!!!
0 reply
June 2016

OMG that was so intense !

OMG that was so intense !
0 reply
October 2015

This moment was very scary ! But I loved Nathan and Lucas in this episode !

This moment was very scary ! But I loved Nathan and Lucas in this episode !
0 reply
666
October 2015

Intense

Intense
0 reply
September 2017

"you're always saving me." 😭😭😭

"you're always saving me." 😭😭😭
0 reply
January 2018

Watching OTH again 10 years later, I’m 25 years old and I still want a Nathan Scott for me. Guess I’ll just give up.

0 reply
December 2015

Oooooooh

Oooooooh
0 reply
June 2018

That was terrifying. Poor Peyton 😢

That was terrifying. Poor Peyton 😢
0 reply
March 2016

Peytons real brother is such a cutie

0 reply
August 2017

Holy Jesus 😱

Holy Jesus 😱
0 reply
August 2015

That was terrifying! Poor Peyton! Hasn't she been through enough??!??!

0 reply

Episode emotions

How was it?

9.8/10

Episode favorite character

According to you, who was the most awesome character in this episode?

loading