Susan Darell (Joan Fontaine), a successful dramatic actress, returns to New York City from a tour entertaining the troops overseas. She is about to marry Richard Aiken (Walter Abel), even though they have only known each other for a few weeks. Then Richard discovers that Susan has an ex-husband (and her current Broadway theatre producer) named Roger Berton (George Brent) and two other former boyfriends when he sees their pictures in her living room.